| Trend-pullback scalper (M1 / M5 / M15) | PF 0.98 / 0.89 / 0.73 with real ticks | REJECTED |
| Pullback scalper + ADX trend filter | No improvement | REJECTED |
| Machine learning, 145 indicators (M5) | PF 0.96 on unseen data | REJECTED |
| Machine learning, 27 H1 setups | Best setup PF 0.66 on unseen data | REJECTED |
| AI as a trade filter (442 signals) | No reliable difference between accepted and rejected trades | REJECTED |
| US news surprise on gold | PF 1.20 / 1.70 / 2.06 by period · MT5 real ticks PF 2.20 | KEPT |
| Spike fade after big H1 candles | PF 1.15 but 35% drawdown | REJECTED |
| Momentum stop-order scalper | +$16,900 in default tester → −$995 with real ticks | REJECTED |
| News strategy on silver | PF 0.77 after costs | REJECTED |
| US news on 7 forex pairs | PF 0.81–1.07 | REJECTED |
| Daily trend following, 8 markets | −4.6% a year after costs and swap | REJECTED |
| AI reading 80 Fed statements | PF 0.60 | REJECTED |
| Foreign news on their own currency | EUR 0.65 · GBP 0.79 · JPY 0.44 | REJECTED |
| US news on indices & US stocks | PF 0.85–0.91 | REJECTED |
| News trades: let winners run / size by surprise / wait for confirmation | No real improvement | REJECTED |
| H1 channel (Donchian) breakout | PF 0.83–0.92 | REJECTED |
| Daily volatility breakout on gold | PF 1.18 in both periods | KEPT |
| + skip extreme-range days and NFP / CPI / Fed days | PF 1.24 / 1.31 · MT5 real ticks PF 1.29 | KEPT |
| Breakout: 1% risk sizing, trend filter, trailing or 2R exits | No improvement on unseen data | REJECTED |
| Previous-day, wide-level and weekly breakouts; silver breakout | Failed the pass rule | REJECTED |
| Failed-breakout reversal | PF 1.50 (2012–21) → 0.75 (2022–26) | REJECTED |
| Tight-stop, 7× target session breakout | PF 0.57–1.00 | REJECTED |
| Asian-range fade | PF 0.72–0.76 | REJECTED |
| H1 EMA swing trend, 1:2 target | PF 0.77–0.95 | REJECTED |
| Breakout rules on 14 other markets | None passed in both periods | REJECTED |
| Forex intraday fade (5 pairs) | PF 0.77–0.89 | REJECTED |
| London breakout of the Asian range (8 markets) | Combined PF 0.95 | REJECTED |
| "Smart money" structure break + retest (9 markets) | PF 0.78–0.88 | REJECTED |